Retain The Most Qualified New Jersey Private Investigator To Gather Evidence In New Jersey Child Custody Cases

New Jersey Private Investigator Gathering Evidence In Child Custody Cases 

Former Jersey City Police Chief Robert Cowan addresses the public in City Hall as Mayor Steve Fulop, Police Director Jim Shea and Members of the City Council look on.

New Jersey Child Custody Motions before a New Jersey Family Court will require the involvement of a Licensed Private Investigator in order to have any chance of being successful; the hiring of a New Jersey Private Investigator is only subordinated by the hiring of a competent Family Law Attorney with experience in litigating Child Custody Issues between parents before a New Jersey Family Court.  In Child Custody Motions before a Family Court the hiring of a Private Investigator is often critical to the conclusion of a Child Custody Motion.  Retaining the most qualified New Jersey Private Investigator is of paramount importance; you want to hire a Private Investigator who possesses the proper investigative background coupled with a long history and background in New Jersey Municipal Law Enforcement with multiple disciplines and extensive training in New Jersey Law, such as:

1.  New Jersey Juvenile Laws and Procedures,

2.  New Jersey Child Abuse and Child Endangerment Laws, to include sexual offenses specifically against children

3.  New Jersey Domestic Violence Policies and Procedures as they relate to the differing responsibilities of Police, County Prosecutors and County Courts,

4.  New Jersey Criminal Code 2C and their application to the above,

5.  A good understanding of New Jersey’s Megan’s law and the policies and procedures, which surround same

5.  A solid background of Experience interacting with the New Jersey Division Of Youth and Family Services (DYFS)

This is not an exclusive list.

Divorcing a spouse involves a multitude of significant and emotionally taxing issues such as the division of finances including liquid assets, pensions, stocks as well as Property such as cars, homes and their contents etc.  However, there is nothing potentially more emotionally devastating than a contested and protracted Child Custody fight in a New Jersey Family Court.  In order to prevail in a New Jersey Child Custody Motion it will often be very expensive with costs to include attorney and private investigators fees, in addition to costs of professionals that may be ordered by the Court such as forensic psychologists, guardian ad-litems, parenting coordinators in addition to other very expensive aspects of plodding through a contested contentious divorce.

When a New Jersey Family Court makes a determination regarding the awarding of custody the first and foremost factor the Family Court will consider is which Child Custody Arrangement will be in the best interest of the child, other factors include (re; N.J.S.A. 9:2-4(c).

  • The parents’ ability to agree, communicate and cooperate in matters relating to the child;
  • The parents’ willingness to accept custody and any history of unwillingness to allow parenting time not based on substantiated abuse;
  • The interaction and relationship of the child with its parents and siblings;
  • The history of domestic violence, if any, including whether or not to here is an active restraining order on one of the parties.  Under the Prevention of Domestic Violence Act, it is presumed that a child’s best interests are served by an award of custody to the non-abusive parent (N.J.S.A. 2C: 25-29(b)(11)).
  • The safety of the child and the safety of either parent from physical abuse by the other parent;
  • The preference of the child when of sufficient age and capacity to reason so as to form an intelligent decision2;
  • The needs of the child;
  • The safety of the child and the safety of either parent from physical abuse by the other parent
  • The quality and continuity of the child’s education;
  • The fitness of the parents;
  • The geographical proximity of the parents’ homes;
  • The extent and quality of the time spent with the child prior to or subsequent to the separation;
  • The parents’ employment responsibilities; and
  • The age and number of the children.

A New Jersey Family Court will have wide latitude in the awarding of Child Custody in a Motion before the Court.  New Jersey Court Rule. 2N.J. Ct. R. 5:8-6 provides that the trial court will have discretion in order to conduct an **“in camera interview of the children” either on its own motion or at the request of either of the litigants https://www.judiciary.state.nj.us/attorneys/assets/rules/r5-8.pdf.    In Lavene v. Lavene, (Superior Court App. Div. 1997): “The age of the child certainly affects the quantum of weight that his/her preference should be accorded, but unless the trial judge expressly finds as a result of its interview either that the child lacks capacity to form an intelligent preference or that the child does not wish to express a preference, the child should be afforded the opportunity to make his/her views known.” https://law.justia.com/cases/new-jersey/appellate-division-published/1977/148-n-j-super-267-0.html

**”In Camera Review”- Most often this refers to hearing or discussions with the judge in the privacy of the Judges Chambers (office) or to a lesser extent, when spectators and jurors have been excluded from the courtroom.

Why Is A New Jersey Private Investigator Critical To Assist In A Child Custody Motion Before A New Jersey Family Court?

When you conference with a New Jersey Family Law Attorney in reference to seeking either an initial Child Custody Order in a contested divorce or a Change of Custody Order because of changed circumstances before a one of the first things this attorney will ask is why the child/children best interests would be served by you having primary physical and/or legal custody. After you verbally explain to this attorney why the child/children are best served being in your custody the lawyer will ask what evidence can you provide to the New Jersey Family Court in order to substantiate your view of the custody status. If you are like many people I have met over the years you might have some compelling evidence but surely not enough for your attorney to be confident in the filing of the Child Custody Motion, in most instances your attorney will recommend you retain a Licensed New Jersey Private Investigator to assist you in obtaining additional evidence in support of your Child Custody Motion prior to the filing of the motion in a New Jersey Family Court.

I have previously listed certain factors/elements a New Jersey Family Court will consider in making a decision in awarding Child Custody, although a New Jersey Private Investigator cannot often obtain evidence on all factors under consideration a competent New Jersey Private Investigator can often gather evidence on a multitude of factors the New Jersey Family Court will consider; what follows is examples of how a New Jersey Private Investigator can gather evidence.

Factors or elements the Court will consider:

  • Parents’ ability to agree, communicate and cooperate in matters relating to the child; (A New Jersey Private Investigator can review documents, interview family, friends, coaches, or other adults who might be willing to get involved on this particular factor and whether or not there is cooperation or whether one parent is particularly uncooperative. This can be included into a report that could be entered into evidence).
  • Parents’ willingness to accept custody and any history of unwillingness to allow parenting time not based on substantiated abuse; (As stated above, A New Jersey Private Investigator often reviews documents, interviews family, friends, coaches, or other adults who might be willing to get involved on this particular factor and whether or not there is cooperation or whether one parent is particularly uncooperative. This can be included into a report that could be entered into evidence).
  • History of Domestic Violence, if any, including whether or not to here is an active restraining order on one of the parties; Under the Prevention of Domestic Violence Act, it is presumed that a child’s best interests are served by an award of custody to the non-abusive parent (N.J.S.A. 2C:25-29(b)(11)). (This factor alone is why it is critical the New Jersey Private Investigator you retain has a Law Enforcement Background in a Municipal New Jersey Police Department; this will ensure that he/she is utterly familiar with and has had hands on experience with domestic violence and its victims as well as having had extensive training every year they were employed as law enforcement officers in a municipality. It is quite possible that a New Jersey Family Court would make a decision on a Child Custody matter based soley on the existence of a history of Domestic Violence).
  • Safety of the child and the safety of either parent from physical abuse by the other parent; (For the reasons stated above, it is of paramount importance you retain a New Jersey Private Investigator who has Law Enforcement Experience in a New Jersey Municipal Police Department).
  • Fitness of the Parents; (A New Jersey Private Investigator can gather evidence of an unfit parent through surveillance and other investigative methods which could include under cover operations, seizing and searching trash for evidence of alcohol or drug abuse in addition to background checks, this is not an exclusive list)
  • Extent and quality of the time spent with the child prior to or subsequent to the separation; (A New Jersey Private Investigator can assist in gathering of evidence of the quality of time spent with a parent through surveillance. Is a child always being left with a baby sitter or some other alternate care? Who are the people around the child, what are their backgrounds?)

In closing, it is very important to perform your “due diligence” before you hire a New Jersey Private Investigator to assist you in gathering evidence in your Child Custody Case. I recommend that at the very least the very you make two inquiries:

#1- What type of equipment does the Private Investigator have? Does he or she have dedicated Surveillance vehicles where it is possible for the private investigator to remain inside the vehicle? What type of cameras does the private investigator deploy in the field? Does the private investigator provide both time and date stamped video and photographs? What kind of reports does the private investigator provide to you and how often? Does the Private Investigator sub-contract “Your Investigation” out to other private investigators?

#2- Does the private investigator have a website?

One of best measures to utilize in determining the competence of a private investigator you are considering retaining is to check out his or her website. A private investigator who would put up a substandard website online for public consumption is a strongly indicative that the private investigator is lazy, non-caring or they just don’t have the ability to put a professional face to their business; I can assure you that if you retain a private investigation firm with either no website or a substandard website do not think for a moment that the work product you obtain from these investigation firms will be any better then their website.

 

For more info, please visit our Child Custody page.

_________________________________________________________

Bob Cowan is the owner of Cowan Investigations a full service New Jersey Private Investigations Firm

 

If you wish to speak with me regarding this article, or if you need a consultation regarding it’s contents please do not hesitate to call me at 732-837-8444, seven days a week 8:00am to 8:00pm.  

About the author: Bob Cowan is the owner of Cowan Investigations a full service New Jersey Private Investigations Firm, Bob is the former Chief of the Jersey City Police Department and has 35 years experience as a police officer.