Child Custody Interstate Relocation

Get Started Today

Contact Our Team

As The Former Chief Of The Jersey City Police Department And Current Owner Of A Licensed New Jersey Private Investigation Firm As Well As Being An Active Private Investigator In The Field, I Strive To Provide Information Relative To My Business. Cowan Investigations Specializes In Child Custody Issues And Is Constantly Keeping Up On All Relavent Case Law In Order That I May Serve My Clients Better.

My writings are not to be construed to lead one to believe I come an any where close to possessing the knowledge of New Jersey Family Law that a qualified and Licensed New Jersey Family Law Attorney Does. However, as a Fully Licensed New Jersey Private Investigator that specializes in divorce related issues, specifically Child Custody Issues as well as Alimony and Cohabitation Matters I find that in order to provide competent service to clients it is imperative I am on top of the constant changing landscape of Case Law Related To New Jersey Family Law. As a New Jersey Private Investigator I take pride in the fact that when a potential client contacts me regarding a divorce related issue I am able to discuss the issue intelligently with him or her rather then pretend to have a basis of knowledge of the cutting edge case law as many New Jersey Private Investigators try to get away with while consulting with clients. Rest assured, if I have an article posted regarding a particular legal case such as this article it means three things, 1. I read the case, 2. I understand what I read, and 3. I possess enough knowledge to have a conversation about the subject matter.

Regardless of the subject matter of a particular New Jersey Court Ruling in a Family Court Matter there always the potentiality for the necessity of the involvement of a New Jersey Private Investigator, even in a matter such as the Relocation of a child out of state as the case I have cited below is about. The 2017, New Jersey Supreme Court Ruling in Bisbing V. Bisbing is an interesting and required read for anyone being divorced and entering into any type of child custody agreements, as you will see, it is critical to know what you are signing and only sign after conferring with a qualified New Jersey Family Law Attorney. For the convenience of my readers I have summarized the Court Rulings and also provided links to several of the Court Rulings.

Summary Of Recent New Jersey Supreme Court Ruling On Interstate Relocation Of Children With Respect To Child Custody Orders

https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=12486670217454289722&hl=en&as_sdt=6&as_vis=1&oi=scholarr

In Bisbing V. Bisbing A Child Custody Interstate Relocation Case The New Jersey Supreme Court Set New Parameters To be Considered When These Cases Are Analyzed By The Trial Court. Essentially The Trial Court Dis Not In Essence Set New Precedent But Returned To The “Best Interests Of The Child Test”. The Supreme Court summary Is attached As A Link For The Convenience Of Readers, In Summary, the case went as follows:

In early 2013, Glenn investigated job opportunities in Colorado and California. The parties separated in August, and in November of that year, Jaime began a long-distance relationship with a resident of Utah who had children from a previous marriage. The Utah resident is the owner of a business in Idaho and also has business interests that require him to travel frequently to California and Louisiana.

On March 8, 2014, the parties entered into a marital settlement agreement (MSA) following the parties’ participation, without counsel, in mediation with an attorney-mediator. The parties agreed to joint legal custody. They agreed that Jaime would have primary residential custody, with the condition that she not relocate out of state.

Pursuant to Article 1.2 of the MSA, Jaime also agreed to “broad, reasonable and liberal timesharing” of the children with Glenn. Glenn was provided parenting time with his daughters on Father’s Day, Glenn’s birthday, “every other weekend and on one weeknight during the weeks when he does not have parenting time.” Glenn had parenting time on two continuous weeks during the summer; and every other Thanksgiving, Christmas Eve, Christmas Day, New Year’s Eve, New Year’s Day, and the children’s school breaks. Under Article 1.3, both parties were also “entitled to attend all of the Children’s sporting and extracurricular activities no matter whose parenting day they might fall on.”

Article 1.9 Relocation provides the following terms regarding a change of residence:

The parties agree that each shall inform the other with respect to any change of residence concerning himself or herself or the said minor Children for the period of time wherein any provision contained in this Agreement remains unfulfilled. The parties represent that they both will make every effort to remain in close proximity, within a fifteen (15) minute drive from the other. Neither party shall permanently relocate with the Children from the State of New Jersey without the prior written consent of the other. Neither parent shall relocate intrastate further than 20 miles from the other party. In the event either party relocates more than 20 miles from the other party, the parties agree to return to mediation to review the custody arrangement. In the event a job would necessitate a move, the parties agree to discuss this together and neither will make a unilateral decision. Neither party shall travel with the minor 538 *538 Children outside of the United States without the prior written consent of the other party.

The parties hereby acknowledge that the Children’s quality of life and style of life are provided equally by Husband and Wife.

The parties hereby acknowledge a direct causal connection between the frequency and duration of the Children’s contact with both parties and the quality of the relationship of the Children and each party.

The parties hereby acknowledge that any proposed move that relocates the Children any further away from either party may have a detrimental impact upon the frequency and duration of the contact between the Children and the non-moving party.

On April 16, 2014, a final judgment of divorce (JOD) was entered incorporating the MSA. According to Glenn, after the divorce, he was “intricately involved in all aspects of the girls’ lives.” He coached their soccer team, took them to ski club activities, and attended their school events.

One month after the divorce, Jaime sent an e-mail to Glenn informing him that, although she received no alimony, she was planning to leave her job on July 1, 2014, to become a full-time stay-at-home parent, which she did.

On January 8, 2015, less than nine months after the divorce, Jaime called Glenn to notify him of her intention to get married to the Utah resident and relocate to Utah. Jaime asked for Glenn’s permission to move with their daughters to Utah. Glenn refused, stating, “You can move, just leave the girls with me.”

On March 16, eleven months after the divorce, Jaime filed a motion seeking to relocate with the children to Utah without the need for a plenary hearing. The court granted the motion allowing relocation without holding a plenary hearing on the condition that a visitation schedule be established through mediation, signing the order on April 24, 2015. On July 14, 2015, after an unsuccessful mediation, with only Jaime suggesting a parenting plan, the court issued a supplemental order establishing a parenting time and communication schedule using most of Jaime’s suggestions.^[2]

Eleven days later, Jaime and the children “left for a vacation to Utah.” Three days thereafter, Jaime permanently relocated with the children in Utah.

NEW JERSEY SUPERIOR TRIAL COURT RULING

In it’s Ruling the trial court applied the standard set forth in this Court’s decision in Baures v. Lewis, 167 N.J. 91, 118-20, 770 A.2d 214 (2001). Under Baures, a parent with primary custody seeking to relocate children out of state over the objection of the other parent must demonstrate only that there is a good-faith reason for an interstate move and that the relocation “will not be inimical to the child’s interests.”

NEW JERSEY APPELLATE COURT REVERSAL OF TRIAL COURT

Defendant appealed, and an Appellate Division panel reversed the trial court’s judgment. https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=239158912288896629&hl=en&as_sdt=6&as_vis=1&oi=scholarr The panel held that if defendant were to make a showing on remand that plaintiff had negotiated the parties’ custody agreement in bad faith, the trial court should not apply the “inimical to the child’s interest” standard of Baures but should instead determine whether relocation would be in the best interests of the child. The panel thus imposed on a plaintiff who has negotiated a custody arrangement in bad faith a higher burden of proof on the question of “cause” under N.J.S.A. 9:2-2 than the burden imposed under Baures

NEW JERSEY SUPREME COURT AFFIRMS AND MODIFIES NEW JERSEY APPELLATE COURT RULING

The New Jersey Supreme Court affirmed and modified the Appellate Division’s judgment. “We depart from the two-part test that Baures prescribed for a relocation application brought by a parent of primary residence. We apply the same standard to all interstate relocation disputes under N.J.S.A. 9:2-2 in which the parents share legal custody — cases in which one parent is designated as the parent of primary residence and the other is designated as the parent of alternate residence and cases in which custody is equally shared. In all such disputes, the trial court should decide whether there is “cause” under N.J.S.A. 9:2-2 to authorize a child’s relocation out of state by weighing the factors set forth in N.J.S.A. 9:2-4, and other relevant considerations, and determining 1157*1157 whether the relocation is in the child’s best interests”.

____________________________________________________________________________________

About the author: Bob Cowan is the owner of Cowan Investigations a full-service New Jersey Private Investigations Firm, Bob is the former Chief
of the Jersey City Police Department and has 35 years experience as a police officer in New Jersey’s second-largest municipality.

If you wish to speak with me regarding this article, or if you need a consultation regarding it’s contents please do not hesitate to call me at 732-837-8444, seven days a week 8:00am to 8:00pm.

Cowan Investigations, LLC. Is licensed, bonded and fully insured to operate in the State of New Jersey.

Cowan Investigations, LLC. New Jersey State Agency License # 9364

Member of New Jersey Private
Investigators Association

Navigation

Contact Our Team

Office Phone
732-837-8444
Email
bobcowaninvestigations@gmail.com
Office
Our Main office is located in Toms River, NJ. In-person consultations by appointment only at our Lacey Township Office.

Google Rating

5.0

Cowan Investigations

5.0

Anthony S

01:44 06 Mar 20

Best of the Best!Worked with Bob during his tenure as the former Chief of the Jersey City Police Department. All I can say is that you will be getting what you pay for with this results driven company.A leader within the industry with over 34+ years in law enforcement as well as a proven track record of accomplishments in the field. If I needed a private investigator, Cowan Investigations would be my first choice, hands down.

Jay White

14:26 14 Jan 20

As a retired Deputy Police Chief with the Jersey City Police Department I had the privilege of working with Bob Cowan for over 25 years. Bob is an honest and ethical professional who shows empathy towards people in unfortunate situations. Bob’s objective analysis and evaluation of an issue enables him to address the true problem at hand. His strong analytical abilities coupled with thorough research and attention to detail make him an ideal private investigator. I know his clients will receive a comprehensive detailed report that will stand up in any hearing or court of law. Bob is a high caliber dedicated professional who will give it his all to address the issues at hand and achieve results.

Rae

23:17 08 Nov 19

I would highly recommend Cowan Investigations. From the time you speak to Liz on the phone until the time Bob is finished with the investigation you will always know what is going on, what is taking place, and what they found. You will be provided with detailed information and surveillance. Bob is very well trained in this field and will provide you with outstanding work. Both Bob and Liz are very compassionate and caring people and make you feel comfortable through the whole process. At the end of the investigation you’ll know that you have hired the right people for the job.

Sarah V

11:00 14 Oct 19

I have been married for over 25 years, 2 years ago things just started not feeling right, I started having suspicions that my husband was cheating. I felt trapped, I was embarrassed to talk about it with anyone. I put up with feeling this way for two years. I began researching private investigators because I was fed up with being lied to and deceived, talked to like I was crazy. I called a few investigators but I did not feel comfortable, I felt like I was talking to used car salesmen. Just before I was going to give up I called Cowan Investigations. From the minute I began speaking to Liz Cowan I began to feel comfortable, she was very genuine, caring and knowledgeable on how to proceed. Liz set up a call with Bob who I immediately could tell was very experienced and knew how to proceed.Over a 4 day period Bob and Joe uncovered the evidence I needed to confront the lies and other deceptions I was subjected to, which let me make the decisions I needed to make for myself. Above all I was able to regain my self respect by getting the proof I needed.From time Liz answered the phone until Bob and Joe finished the investigation, I was overwhelmed by the professionalism and caring they displayed towards me and the investigation.Thanks again Liz, Bob and Joe, you’re the best

Susie K

14:01 25 Oct 19

I recently had the need to use a private investigator. After looking at several options, I decided to call Cowan Investigations. The decision to call them turned out to be one of the best decisions I ever made. I really like the fact that Mr. Cowan has a law enforcement background and is a former Chief of Police for Jersey City. After my first conversation with Liz Cowan I knew I had called the right people. She made me feel very comfortable when I answered all the questions she needed to get the facts regarding a very complicated situation. Liz is very thorough, caring, and very professional and usually available when I had questions. Liz and Bob make you, their priority. I NEVER had to worry if Mr. Cowan would be working on my case at the time I was promised. He was always at the location, on time, very descrete and went way above and beyond my expectations. I was informed of the progress on a daily basis and over a period of 4-5 days, had enough evidence to prove my case. The reports are very professionally written with dates and time stamped. It says a lot when my lawyer called Bob Cowan and complimented him on the great report he gave to my lawyer, to take to court. I feel the evidence gathered by Cowan Investigations and presented to the judge, by my lawyer, made a huge difference in the judge's decision. I met Mr. Cowan and shook his hand after I won the case. I highly recommend Cowan Investigations and will definitely use them again if needed. Thank you for all your hard work, you are the best!

Megan Parker

10:21 14 Sep 20

I approached Cowan Investigations from out of state with a delicate situation that needed to be handled in NJ and Liz made me feel at ease and in good hands immediately! Both Liz and Bob reviewed my case and got back to be the same day with a great price and additional suggestions to make sure I was satisfied with the planning they had come up with. It was important to me for all parties involved in my case to feel comfortable and Liz and Bob definitely fit the bill! They took the time to gather all the information needed and completely exceeded my expectations. I originally chose to call Cowan Investigations because of the professional website and Bob's credentials, but it was the personal care and service that cemented their agency for me. Thanks again Liz!!

Allison Kaplan

14:37 25 Nov 20

If you find yourself in need of a PI, I can assure you that retaining Cowan Investigations is 100% the right choice. Bob and his wife Liz worked tirelessly to assist me with a very challenging situation and ultimately were able to exceed my highest expectations in terms of obtaining evidence. I truly cannot thank them enough for the level of care and professionalism they brought to my case.

W. N. D. Movie Reviews

21:13 24 Jul 20

I didn't personally have the pleasure of meeting Mr. Cowan but Liz was so incredibly efficient and professional!! Within hrs she had already gotten answers to a question that has tormented me for a long time.If you need ANY investigative work done trust Cowan. This was my 1st time dealing with an investigative service and I was best pleased!! 5 stars all the way! A special thank you to Liz. You're a dear and I will always remember your warmth, sympathy and professionalism. Always.YoursTom

Tri State

20:34 30 Jun 21

I am a business owner and I contacted Cowan Investigations regarding a business matter I was involved in. I was impressed by the promptness and thoroughness of their work. I am happy I called because they uncovered a lot of pertinent information I was not aware of. Would definitely recommendSheldon

Carlos Mariano

20:22 03 Jun 21

Liz and Bob, thank you so much for everything you've done for me. For years I've tried getting information on a certain person in the family and it was just impossible. You went above and beyond and got me all the info I needed. I would definitely give you 10 stars but unfortunately there's only five to give . Once again thank you for everything you've done for me and my family.

See All Reviews